Friday, October 30, 2009

I wish i had 4.7 billion to lose.

Sony released a statement today claiming that the PS3 has cost the company 4.7 billion dollars since its release.

4.7 billion.


That is a staggering number to look at, especially in terms of dollars. Now, Sony claims that the console will be profitable within a year, which is great for them, but why do we care? Does it matter that Microsoft lost the same amount on the original Xbox? When did this information become important?

Normally I don't pay a lot of attention to the bottom line of the Big 3. Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo are not going to go bankrupt anytime soon, and even when they hemorrhage cash like a hemophiliac shaving for the first time, we know that they will soldier on. What this number highlights is why these three companies, especially Sony, are pushing for digital distribution so hard recently. The fact that I was 5 might have something to do with it, but I don't remember Nintendo informing the world about how much money they lost on the NES. Sega didn't mention it with the Genesis. However, now that we have the internet, and with it a pack of wild carrion pecking at any scrap of meat that is remotely digestible, information that would normally be shared at board meetings and sent out to share holders becomes public the moment it whispers out. The reason the PS3 became so reviled and seen as a failure was not becaue of the price, but of Sony trying to justify the price by crying about how much money they would lose on the sale. I know that I certainly shed a sympathetic tear with them while I was eating my ramen noodles and trying to save up for toilet paper.

What we learned seemed like a new revelation, but it is actually industry standard. Companies make their big bucks on the sale of games, not the system. They are, for all intents and purposes, paying to have their system in our living rooms as a future investment. There is nothing ground breaking about this, other than the fact that now we get to hear about it. 20 years ago the losses didn't seem so steep, and the retail profits of games were sturdier for the companies. The evolution of the used game market and Gamestop shifted the paradigm of the industry. It costs more and more to produce a game, and while Gamestop makes next to nothing on new game sales, the existence of used games inspires a lot of consumers to wait for a cheaper version. That cut in sales can multiply quickly, so another revenue stream is needed.

That is where the digital push comes in. If Sony can charge us $60 for a game in the stores AND in the digital arena, where would they want the emphasis to go? They make 100% of the profit on line, where they have to pay for the manufacturing and creation of physical media, and then give retail outlets $5-10 out of the sale. With digital distribution, Sony can charge the same amount, but make their money back twice as fast. They will also have no reason to drop game prices as quickly as they do now. Not a bad deal all around.

In the end, all that matters to us is that the games produced are solid. The quality of games has risen dramatically over the last few years, and as long as the games are worth the price tag, gamers won't argue. The question is, will the Big 3 continue to make that quality when they control the entire market? It will be interesting to see how they handle the next big shift.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Uncharted 2

One of the many justified complaints about the Playstation 3 is the limited library. Since it launched, the lack of first party titles and exclusive games has been a point of contention for fans and detractors alike. The strategy and games that made Sony a behemoth for decades in the gaming industry seemed to be shed from the emerging new system, leaving fans with precious little to hold onto. Finally, after years of bickering on message boards and all of those lonely, doubt-filled nights, PS3 owners can see the light at the end of the tunnel. With the release of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves this week, Sony has finally laid out its hand and shown us what the system can offer. The result is a game that grabs onto the player from the opening scene and propels them through a cinematic rollercoaster with fewer stops.
The original Uncharted ended up being a quiet hit. The game was loved and lauded by the Sony community, but it was overlooked by the majority of gamers and the public at large; the game failed to crack the top 10 after its release. However, the fans around the game multiplied as word of mouth spread, and it gradually started to build a loyal and passionate following. The pulp-esque adventure of Nathan Drake, his partner in crime Sully and the intrepid reporter Elena struck a chord with gamers, and the phenomenal presentation and game play helped add to the hype surrounding it. Thankfully, the clamor became such that Naughty Dog was given the chance to present a sequel and pull out all the stops in the process.
Presenting a good follow up to any game is all about keeping what works while adding enough that the game still feels fresh. The core mechanics we became accustomed to in Uncharted are still here; the game is in third person, the shooting reticle is identical, and you are still forced to scale walls and buildings. Naughty Dog kept these while improving on certain points, mainly stealth and cover. One of the major complaints about the first game is Nate’s inability to leave cover when needed. Among Thieves has solved that issue, and transitioning from one area to the next is now seamless. This small addition makes combat much more smooth and enjoyable. The added stealth element also adds a new winkle to the game. While using the stealth is entirely optional save for a small part in the beginning of the game, it makes Among Thieves are far more tactical and enjoyable game. Moving up behind enemies or, more often, hanging from a ledge below them, allows you to take them down silently and quickly. Pulling these sneak attacks is not only helpful to avoid huge throngs of enemies, but the attacks themselves are varied and often exhilarating. Hand to hand combat is also much improved, removing the button mashing of the first game and adding a timed parry and block to your repertoire. While it is a small addition, it makes engaging in hand to hand combat far more interesting and enjoyable.
As before, the AI in Uncharted 2 is superb. The enemies you face are smart, use cover very effectively and move in packs, combining armored soldiers with snipers and gunners to keep you pinned down. What is different this time around is the regular companionship of a partner. Typically, the knowledge of having an AI counterpart is a horrifying concept; anyone that has suffered through Resident Evil 5 on their own can attest to that. Somehow, Naughty Dog managed to craft AI partners that were always near, constantly shooting enemies yet never getting in your way. You never have to care for them or watch for their safety, and that means you can concentrate on what you are doing as a player while occasionally getting saved from hairy situations. Going into the game this was the part I had the most reservations about, but it ended up being a welcome change.
Another cornerstone of the Uncharted experience that was improved was the puzzle sections. The first game featured platforming puzzles as well as more traditional puzzles. Uncharted 2 involves far more platforming puzzles; the straight forward ones you come across are far more in-depth and require more of you as a player. The change is noticeable and welcome, making for a much more involved experience on all levels. To help you solve these puzzles you have a journal once again, however this time it is Nate’s journal and features pages of sketches and jokes that kept me preoccupied far more often than I’d like to admit. As the game goes on the journal expands, which kept me going back time after time. The platforming aspect works much like the original, just on a larger scale. All of the areas are bigger in both size and complexity, but that never hinders your movement through them. The only noticeable difference is the lack of SixAxis compatibility when crossing bridges. I love an under-supported Sony peripheral as much as the next guy, but I wasn’t sad to see that part missing as I climbed around.
On top of the pristine combat system and puzzles employed by Uncharted 2, the sheer visual polish present in the game is mind boggling. One of the most breathtaking moments I have ever experienced in video games came while standing on top of a building and looking over the city of Nepal. Not only can you count the individual cobblestones on the streets below, but you can see every rooftop and mountain peak clearer than you would be able to in person. The draw distance is amazing throughout, which allows for the breathtaking scenery you scale across to be more grandiose this time around. Naughty Dog set out to make a playable action movie, and they succeeded. The camera angles are able to be wide, to pan around impressive and daunting obstacles and add tension and awe to an already tense situation. The visual masterpiece set up allows for a game that constantly crosses into film territory in its size and scope. This attention to detail isn’t limited to the expansive world around Nate and company, but is present in the character builds as well. Every character is crafted beautifully, with every hair noticeable and every thread of their deteriorating outfits moving in concert with your actions. The effect is breathtaking to watch.
While there is certainly a lot to discuss with Uncharted 2, what sets it apart for many is its ability to suck us into the story and the characters. All of the staple actors are back as well as a few new faces including Claudia Black of Pitch Black and Farscape fame as Chloe. While the story is straight out of the pulp novels of the 1950’s, it is thrilling none the less. This time the story takes you across the world, giving variety to the game play and the backdrop for the actors. Everyone in the game gives a fantastic performance, and the humor is present throughout the game. Many of the jokes are intentionally lame and heavily reliant on the puns, but the jokes are sold so well by the actors that you can’t help but painfully grin and Nate’s not-too-subtle flirting and Elena’s constant exasperation at Nate’s antics. Even the bad guys play their villainous roles with gusto, teetering on the brink of cheesy but never falling over. As the story become larger, the characters keep it grounded and exciting, an effort that is seldom seen in the gaming world.
As I played through Uncharted 2, knowing that I would write about it, I kept trying to find flaws. Nate occasionally feels a little too lose and uncontrollable and the platforming is sometimes a bit too easy and straightforward. However, I had to really nitpick to find faults, and that alone should tell you how fantastic this game is, and that was just through the single player mission. The multiplayer addition to Uncharted 2, while too long to go into here, is just as amazing as the game itself. Naughty Dog created a game that feels more like a summer blockbuster than a game; it’s what the last Indiana Jones movie should have been. The game grabs onto you from the outset and continues to rocket you across continents and through battlefields without ever letting up. Putting the game down to sleep was an exercise in willpower I wasn’t sure I had. The affection put into making the game is infectious, and Uncharted 2 will certainly be on the tips of every PS3 owners tongue when asked about why someone should buy a PS3; and it will be hard to argue against that.

Saturday, October 17, 2009

Demon Soul's Review

It has been a very long time since I became so frustrated with a video game that I felt the need to launch a controller across the room. The last time I remember such frustration was after an hour long battle with the Emerald Weapon in Final Fantasy VII, finally culminating in my death, and that was only one moment. Demon Souls has proven itself to be a game capable and eager to provide those moments in abundance. I imagine that the number of Playstaion controllers sold during the month of October will spike as Demon Souls makes its way into game library’s across the country.
We’ve been hearing that Demon Souls is hard for months now; every review and preview is prefaced with this fact. Most of us took these statements with a grain of salt as game writers are known for their penchant for hyperbole. It turns out that this time, we were not being misled. The one word that will come to mind over and over as you play is “hard.” Demon Souls is not a forgiving game, and that is what makes its creation, release and game play so triumphant. It has been decades since we saw a game this difficult and rewarding, and the wait was well worth it.
On the surface, Demon Souls seems like a typical RPG. You have knights, demons, dragons and witch’s all battling across a mythic landscape. Games of that nature are a dime a dozen. There is no shortage of fantasy RPG’s on any console, and introducing a new title into the genre doesn’t seem like anything to write home about. Despite the difficulty of surmounting such barriers in the minds of gamers, From Software managed to craft a game that sets itself apart not just from its genre peers, but every other title in the Playstation library.
You begin Demon Souls by creating a character and selecting a class. The stats we’ve grown to know and love are all there; vitality, endurance, strength, intelligence and all the rest are put into the equation while choosing a class. Most RPGs take these into account, but once inside the world of Demon Souls you see how much importance each of these statistics are. Instead of going the route of its peers, Demon Souls takes not only your stats into account, but the build of your weapon, the size and arc of your swing, and the different styles of each different item and how well it suits your character. There are no class limitations on weapons and armor in Demon Souls, but putting an axe into the hands of your mage will result in an instant loss of stamina and a long recovery time before you are allowed to swing again. A two handed weapon in a narrow corridor will only lead to you breaking a weapon on the walls while leaving your enemies unscathed. Every wall, piece of scenery, bead of sweat and pound of armor has a direct, and sometimes major, effect on your game play. Learning which strikes and blocks work in what areas is essential, and the game allows for precious little trial and error, punishing you for any amount of bravado and any experimentation.
The combat is fairly simple in construction. You have two attacks; a weaker, standard attack and a strong but slower attack, bound to R1 and R2 respectively. The left side of the controller controls your off hand for blocking and parrying with a shield, or duel wielding a smaller weapon for attack or disarming. What makes the combat unusual is the way it’s presented. The difficulty in Demon Souls comes from the emphasis on reality From Software placed on the player. Your character is simply human. Your reactions are not lighting quick, you are very vulnerable to every type of attack and you wear down as quickly as a normal person. No matter how high your level reaches, you are never a superhero, simply a strong human. Many enemies will kill you in one or two hits, you can’t scale walls to escape, and simple falls do just as much damage as they would in real life. Add to that the effect of the environment around you on your attacks and movement, and you find yourself having to think and act like you are actually in the game instead of directing the game.
The upgrading system in Demon Souls is also a grueling punishment at times. In order to upgrade your character, buy new weapons and items, or repair your existing equipment, you have to have the currency of the day; demon souls. For every enemy you best you are rewarded with a stock of souls. You use these as gold and as experience, gathering more and more as you progress. After you have collected enough souls, you can travel back to the Nexus, the only hub of safety in the world of cruelty you find yourself stuck in. Here you can enter new areas, upgrade your equipment and rest. You need to continually travel back to the Nexus either through beating a level or traveling to an access point, and the need to do so comes up often; you will become very well accustomed to the Nexus world and the merchant’s desire for the souls you collect.
The curveball here is that upon dying, you lose all of your souls. Regardless of how many you have collected, or where you are, everything you’ve gathered is gone in a puff of smoke once you shed your mortal coil and you begin again at the beginning of the level. You have one chance to redeem yourself and collect your lost souls again, but only if you can make it back to the point of your death without dying again. Since every time you die or leave the level the enemies re-spawn, this is seldom an easy accomplishment. The first time you lose your accrued souls from a forgotten trap, or from an environmental hazard, it will test your resolve and make you wonder if maybe the folks at From Software pulled an elaborate joke on everyone. However, after a few times you realize that you will have to play smarter and more cautiously, and you’ll memorize the world around you and pay keener attention to every detail. Demon Souls forces the player to become immersed in the world more than any other game in recent memory.
We’ve all trained to play games in a similar fashion over the years. Games discs can hold more information, allowing for longer games and deeper game play and negating the need for impossible puzzles and random encounters to lengthen your experience. We are used to being able to jump in and tank through an area, making our character so powerful as the game goes on that death is seldom a worry; if we do die, we have save points and auto saves to put us right back in the fight. The elimination of any saves and the escalating difficulty of Demon Souls makes sure that every step you take could be a fatal mistake. At no point will you be able to plunge into battle against numerous opponents and expect to live. The strategies we’ve polished over the years are suddenly worthless. Demon Souls will force every gamer to learn or relearn a different way of playing, and while the experience in the beginning will force many gamers to give up in disgust, the feeling of accomplishment and relief when you overcome the difficult area or the challenging boss is unlike the experience in any other modern game. This is undoubtedly the most accurate RPG we’ve ever seen, and it is wrapped in a haunting, cinematic world bound within a tragic and chilling tale. Demon Souls is an indispensible addition to the Playstation catalog, and whether you play through the entire game or only a few levels, it will change the way you see video games and role playing games and that is a rare ability in any game.

One of the admittedly many justified complaints about the Playstation 3 is the limited library. Since it launched the lack of first party titles and exclusive games has been a point of contention for fans and detractors alike. The strategy and games that made Sony a behemoth for decades in the gaming industry seemed to be shed from the emerging new system, leaving fans with precious little to hold onto. Finally, after years of bickering on message boards and all of those lonely, doubt-filled nights, PS3 owners can see the light at the end of the tunnel. With the release of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves this week, Sony has finally laid out its hand and shown us what the system can offer. The result is a game that grabs onto the player from the opening scene and propels them through a cinematic rollercoaster with fewer stops.

The original Uncharted ended up being a quiet hit. The game was loved and lauded by the Sony community, but it was overlooked by the majority of gamers and the public at large; the game failed to crack the top 10 after its release. However, the fans around the game multiplied as word of mouth spread, and it gradually started to build a loyal and passionate following. The pulp-esque adventure of Nathan Drake, his partner in crime Sully and the intrepid reporter Elena struck a chord with gamers, and the phenomenal presentation and game play helped add to the hype surrounding it. Thankfully, the clamor became such that Naughty Dog was given the chance to present a sequel and pull out all the stops in the process.

Presenting a good follow up to any game is all about keeping what works while adding enough that the game still feels fresh. The core mechanics we became accustomed to in Uncharted are still here; the game is in third person, the shooting reticle is identical, and you are still forced to scale walls and buildings. Naughty Dog kept these while improving on certain points, mainly stealth and cover. One of the major complaints about the first game is Nate’s inability to leave cover when needed. Among Thieves has solved that issue, and transitioning from one area to the next is now seamless. This small addition makes combat much more smooth and enjoyable. The added stealth element also adds a new winkle to the game. While using the stealth is entirely optional save for a small part in the beginning of the game, it makes Among Thieves are far more tactical and enjoyable game. Moving up behind enemies or, more often, hanging from a ledge below them, allows you to take them down silently and quickly. Pulling these sneak attacks is not only helpful to avoid huge throngs of enemies, but the attacks themselves are varied and often exhilarating. Hand to hand combat is also much improved, removing the button mashing of the first game and adding a timed parry and block to your repertoire. While it is a small addition, it makes engaging in hand to hand combat far more interesting and enjoyable.

As before, the AI in Uncharted 2 is superb. The enemies you face are smart, use cover very effectively and move in packs, combining armored soldiers with snipers and gunners to keep you pinned down. What is different this time around is the regular companionship of a partner. Typically, the knowledge of having an AI counterpart is a horrifying concept; anyone that has suffered through Resident Evil 5 on their own can attest to that. Somehow, Naughty Dog managed to craft AI partners that were always near, constantly shooting enemies yet never getting in your way. You never have to care for them or watch for their safety, and that means you can concentrate on what you are doing as a player while occasionally getting saved from hairy situations. Going into the game this was the part I had the most reservations about, but it ended up being a welcome change.

Another cornerstone of the Uncharted experience that was improved was the puzzle sections. The first game featured platforming puzzles as well as more traditional puzzles. Uncharted 2 involves far more platforming puzzles; the straight forward ones you come across are far more in-depth and require more of you as a player. The change is noticeable and welcome, making for a much more involved experience on all levels. To help you solve these puzzles you have a journal once again, however this time it is Nate’s journal and features pages of sketches and jokes that kept me preoccupied far more often than I’d like to admit. As the game goes on the journal expands, which kept me going back time after time. The platforming aspect works much like the original, just on a larger scale. All of the areas are bigger in both size and complexity, but that never hinders your movement through them. The only noticeable difference is the lack of SixAxis compatibility when crossing bridges. I love an under-supported Sony peripheral as much as the next guy, but I wasn’t sad to see that part missing as I climbed around.

On top of the pristine combat system and puzzles employed by Uncharted 2, the sheer visual polish present in the game is mind boggling. One of the most breathtaking moments I have ever experienced in video games came while standing on top of a building and looking over the city of Nepal. Not only can you count the individual cobblestones on the streets below, but you can see every rooftop and mountain peak clearer than you would be able to in person. The draw distance is amazing throughout, which allows for the breathtaking scenery you scale across to be more grandiose this time around. Naughty Dog set out to make a playable action movie, and they succeeded. The camera angles are able to be wide, to pan around impressive and daunting obstacles and add tension and awe to an already tense situation. The visual masterpiece set up allows for a game that constantly crosses into film territory in its size and scope. This attention to detail isn’t limited to the expansive world around Nate and company, but is present in the character builds as well. Every character is crafted beautifully, with every hair noticeable and every thread of their deteriorating outfits moving in concert with your actions. The effect is breathtaking to watch.

While there is certainly a lot to discuss with Uncharted 2, what sets it apart for many is its ability to suck us into the story and the characters. All of the staple actors are back as well as a few new faces including Claudia Black of Pitch Black and Farscape fame as Chloe. While the story is straight out of the pulp novels of the 1950’s, it is thrilling none the less. This time the story takes you across the world, giving variety to the game play and the backdrop for the actors. Everyone in the game gives a fantastic performance, and the humor is present throughout the game. Many of the jokes are intentionally lame and heavily reliant on the puns, but the jokes are sold so well by the actors that you can’t help but painfully grin and Nate’s not-too-subtle flirting and Elena’s constant exasperation at Nate’s antics. Even the bad guys play their villainous roles with gusto, teetering on the brink of cheesy but never falling over. As the story become larger, the characters keep it grounded and exciting, an effort that is seldom seen in the gaming world.

As I played through Uncharted 2, knowing that I would write about it, I kept trying to find flaws. Nate occasionally feels a little too lose and uncontrollable and the platforming is sometimes a bit too easy and straightforward. However, I had to really nitpick to find faults, and that alone should tell you how fantastic this game is, and that was just through the single player mission. The multiplayer addition to Uncharted 2, while too long to go into here, is just as amazing as the game itself. Naughty Dog created a game that feels more like a summer blockbuster than a game; it’s what the last Indiana Jones movie should have been. The game grabs onto you from the outset and continues to rocket you across continents and through battlefields without ever letting up. Putting the game down to sleep was an exercise in willpower I wasn’t sure I had. The affection put into making the game is infectious, and Uncharted 2 will certainly be on the tips of every PS3 owners tongue when asked about why someone should buy a PS3; and it will be hard to argue against that.

How Beelzebub took over Activision and eventually the world

I can already feel the hot, musky breath of Activions lawyers breathing down my neck as I write this, but what half-baked blogger can really have credibility without being threatened by legal action.

It is becoming more and more apparent that as the video game market expands the casual market to millions of new customers every year while simultaneously creating core games that are becoming more cinematic and more realistic, think Uncharted 2 and Heavy Rain, the money coming into the industry is expanding as well. While gamers may feel that games like the two mentioned above give the industry credibility and substance, it is really the money that gaming generates that has made it acceptable to the mainstream. In the past, when gaming was still a niche market, it was run by people with a passion for the industry, and while they certainly didn't shun the idea of making money, they tried to do what was best for the industry and the people involved in it. When Activision made Bobby Kotick CEO, we saw a shift in the industry that began to choke out competition and creativity. The first hint of trouble was the hiring of a CEO who goes by Bobby as opposed to this more respectable moniker of Robert.

Let us take a look at the sterling track record this year alone from this titan of industry. In September this year, Bobby made a few hilarious statements, one of them being that gaming will eclipse film and television in the near future. Now, i am a firm believer in the idea that games should allow a player to direct the action of a film. Uncharted 2 showed us how camera work and scale can create a better action film in a game than Spielberg and Lucas were able to with the last Indian Jones movie, but can the man who focuses only on titles that are "annualizable" and drops cinematic games like Wet and Brutal Legend really be trusted on this? I imagine that Bob would LOVE to rake in money like film and TV do, and will probably try to accomplish that. The issue is that the games he puts out are garbage. The graphic difference between Marvel Ultimate Alliance 1 and 2 are nearly indistinguishable in game. Prototype looked like a PS2 game with more characters on screen. Activision has yet to release a game that breaks any type of ground on any level. The acting is always subpar, the graphics are close to last gen and the focus on only publishing titles that can have a sequel released the next year dilutes the ability of developers to create anything of substance.

The root of this substance issue in Activision games is Kotick's insistence that game developers not have any fun making the games. Shacknews reported earlier this year about this development. Check out these quotes.

"The company's incentive program 'really rewards profit and nothing else,' adding that 'skepticism, pessimism, and fear' are used to keep employees 'focused on the deep depression.'"

"the goal that I had [at Activision]...about 10 years ago was to take all the fun out of making video games."

Read those again carefully. This man not only uses fear of job lose to motivate the production of games, but wants to make sure that the job is not fun, but focused on profit and sales. He is taking a medium that trades on emotion and enjoyment and is making it a medium of fear and horror that focuses on mediocre gameplay and graphics for quick profit. Instead of going the route of Ubisoft and taking the big profit titles, in Ubi's case the Petz franchise, and then allowing for truly great games to be created, Activision actively sheds original IP's and focuses on another rehash. The loss of Infinity Ward as a contributor, due to Infinity Ward's desire to make war games that take place somewhere other than World War II, is another sign of how formulaic Activision wants to make the industry. We need innovating, not to storm Normandy again.


When you take all of this, along with Kotick's desire to raise game prices even further for both special editions and regular editions, and you have a chilling image of what may come to pass. No one will argue that game companies need to make money, but when the companies begin to give us a cheaper product, less innovations in game play and story, and fewer original titles to choose from and then charge us more (two brand new games are already over a hundred dollars), what will become of the industry as a whole? How long until a large part of the gaming community is simply priced out of their passion? It won't be long until Activision buys out companies that create fantastic pieces or art and simply cuts out anything not adhering to its mission statement of cheap, fast and repetitious. The prestige that games have earned over the last decade could be eroded in a heartbeat.

Thankfully, the used market allows me to boycott Activision games while still being able to play through the few worth mentioning. I would implore any serious gamer to do the same thing. Avoid new Activision games, pick them up a few days later used and save your support for a company that has earned it, because they need it now more than ever.